When do election markets pay out? Not when the polls close, and not when a price hits 99¢. Each venue settles under its own written rules: Kalshi usually once media organisations agree on a projection, Polymarket once named news organisations have all called the race and its resolution process has run. In the 2026 midterms Kalshi settled first in every race we could compare, by a median of 2.6 hours. Close races can take days or weeks.
How fast the 2026 midterm markets actually paid
We read the settlement time of all 129 midterm markets we track, from each venue’s public data, on November 5, 2026. That covers Senate, governor and House races plus the two control markets, the same list as our accuracy report. Polymarket listed 107 of them and Kalshi 127.
| Settled by (Eastern time) | Kalshi (of 127) | Polymarket (of 107) |
|---|---|---|
| Midnight, election night | 51 | 13 |
| 6 a.m., November 4 | 92 | 64 |
| Noon, November 4 | 92 | 71 |
| Midnight, November 4 to 5 | 99 | 77 |
| 7:25 a.m., November 5 | 99 | 78 |
- Kalshi was first every time, at first. In all 77 races that had settled on both venues by November 5, Kalshi got there first, by a median of 2.6 hours. The gap ran from 1.4 hours to 7.1 hours. The pattern didn’t always hold for the late races: Polymarket resolved the Alaska governor’s race at 3:10 a.m. ET on November 14, about six hours before Kalshi settled it at 9:17 a.m. ET.
- Senate control: Kalshi settled at 12:46 a.m. ET on November 4 and Polymarket at 5:53 a.m. ET, a gap of 5.1 hours.
- House control: Kalshi settled at 1:02 a.m. ET and Polymarket at 8:06 a.m. ET, the widest gap at 7.1 hours.
- Most of the rest are real waits. About a quarter of these markets were still open on November 5, including the Mississippi and Alaska Senate races, the Alaska and Kansas governor’s races and a number of House seats where the count isn’t finished.
Polymarket’s times are the close time on its public data, and Kalshi’s are its settlement time. We quote them as they stood on November 5, so the last row will have moved since. The late races, and how each venue did on accuracy, are in our summary, Midterms 2026: how the markets did.
Kalshi: when election markets settle
- Early settlement. Kalshi’s race and control markets are “eligible for accelerated determination” once a consensus of media organisations projects the winner, so most settle soon after the major calls.
- Otherwise, the rules’ fallback. Race markets settle on who is sworn in or inaugurated for the new term. Kalshi’s Senate control market otherwise uses the party of the Senate’s President pro tempore on February 1, 2027, and its House control market the Speaker’s party on the same date.
- Payout. Kalshi says a market settles when the official outcome is confirmed and its markets team finalises the result; winning contracts are then paid to your cash balance. Most markets settle within a few hours of the outcome being known, often within about 3 hours, but it can take longer when Kalshi is waiting on official data.
Polymarket: when election markets resolve
- The calls. Polymarket’s race markets resolve once the Associated Press, Fox News and NBC have all called the race for the same candidate. If they haven’t, the market waits for the official certified result.
- The resolution process. Markets are resolved through the UMA Optimistic Oracle: someone proposes the outcome, and it then goes through a 2-hour challenge period. If the proposal is disputed, resolution takes longer.
- Payout. When a market resolves, winning shares are worth $1 each and losing shares nothing.
- Control markets use official information from state election authorities and Congress plus a consensus of credible reporting. See Senate control and House control for the detail.
Why some 2026 races are taking longer
- Alaska: the AP called the Senate race for Mary Peltola on November 17 with more than half of first choices, so no ranked-choice count was needed. Kalshi closed its market at 10:29 p.m. ET and paid out at 10:59 p.m. ET, and Polymarket resolved it at 1:36 a.m. ET on November 18, and certification is targeted for November 25. See the Alaska Senate race.
- Mississippi: the Senate race was too close to call for a week while affidavit ballots were counted. The AP called it for Scott Colom at 5:58 p.m. ET on November 11. Kalshi closed its market six minutes later and settled it for Colom at 6:34 p.m. ET, 36 minutes after the call. Polymarket, which needs the AP, Fox News and NBC to agree, resolved its market for Colom at 9:06 p.m. ET, about two and a half hours after Kalshi. The state has no automatic recount, so a losing candidate’s route is a legal contest. See the Mississippi Senate race.
- Late-counting states: some states count mail ballots that arrive after election day, so close races there can’t be called on the night. Our election night hub has the state-by-state timetable.
What you can do before settlement
- Sell. You can close a position at the market price at any time before settlement; see how to sell and cash out early.
- Read the rules. The two venues can settle the same race on different events, such as a media call versus who is sworn in. Each of our race pages has a “How this market settles” section.
FAQ
Have the 2026 Senate and House control markets paid out?
How fast does Kalshi pay out on election markets?
How fast does Polymarket pay out?
Why is a called race still trading at 98¢?
What happens if there’s a recount?
Sources, checked November 19, 2026:
- Kalshi help centre: Market FAQs (settlement and payouts)
- Polymarket help centre: How are prediction markets resolved?
- Settlement rules: Polymarket and Kalshi market pages for the 2026 Senate, House and governor races (checked Oct 30, 2026)
- Settlement times: Polymarket and Kalshi public market data (read Nov 5, 2026)
Related: Election night hub · 2026 midterms · How markets resolve disputes · How accurate are prediction markets? · Markets closing this week