PFed Decision in December? · 25 bps increase90%▼3PWhat price will Bitcoin hit in… · ↓ 55,00072%▲28PPelicans vs. Thunder · Jared McCain: Rebounds O/U 3.544%▼3PIsrael x Iran ceasefire continues through...? · November 2297%▲1PWhat price will Bitcoin hit in… · ↑ 60,00065%—PDemocratic Presidential Nominee 2028 · Jon Ossoff25%▼1PRepublican Presidential Nominee 2028 · J.D. Vance29%▼2PWhat price will Bitcoin hit November… · ↑ 60,00035%—PNext French Presidential Election · Marine Le Pen46%—PBitcoin above ___ on November 21? · 56,00086%▼13PWill China invade Taiwan by end of 2026?2%▲1K2028 Democratic presidential nominee · Jon Ossoff24%▼2KNext Senate Democratic Leader? · Chuck Schumer92%▼1PPresidential Election Winner 2028 · Jon Ossoff17%—KWho will be the next CEO… · Rene Haas25%▼2PJensen Huang rejoins NVIDIA by...? · December 31, 202731%▲4K2028 Republican presidential nominee · J.D. Vance31%—PWill Anthropic’s valuation hit __ by… · ↓$1.0T65%▲19PWhat price will Ethereum hit in… · ↓ 1,50070%▲29PUEFA Champions League: 2027 Champion · Barcelona23%—PWhat price will Bitcoin hit on… · ↑ 59,00048%—PPGL Major Singapore 2026: Winner · Vitality30%—PNext CEO of NVIDIA? · Rene Haas25%▼1PWhat price will Ethereum hit November… · ↑ 1,70036%—

Midterms 2026: how the prediction markets did

The summary: how often the favourite won, the Brier scores, the biggest upsets and how fast each venue paid.

How did prediction markets do in the 2026 midterms? With every race on our list now called, this is the summary. It draws on two of our own records: the prices of 129 markets on Polymarket and Kalshi at 4 p.m. ET on election day, scored against the results, and the times each venue paid out. The race-by-race detail is in our accuracy report, and the payout rules in when election markets pay out.

Prices taken4 p.m. ET, November 3, 2026
Races scored129 of 129
Favourite wonPolymarket 91/107 · Kalshi 110/127
Results as ofNovember 18, 2026

The findings

  • The favourite usually won. Polymarket’s 4 p.m. favourite won 91 of the 107 races it listed (85%), and Kalshi’s won 110 of 127 (87%).
  • The venues were close on the same races. On the 105 races both venues listed, the Brier scores were 0.103 for Polymarket and 0.104 for Kalshi, almost identical. Across all the races each listed, Kalshi’s average was lower, 0.086 against 0.101, mainly because it listed more safe seats.
  • Close races were close to a coin flip. Where the favourite was priced under 65%, it won 14 of 26 times on Polymarket and 11 of 23 on Kalshi.
  • Both chambers went to the favourite. Democrats were at 95% on Polymarket and 93% on Kalshi to win the House, and 75% and 73% to win the Senate. They won both, flipping nine Senate seats for 54 Democrats, 2 independents and 44 Republicans.
  • The venues disagreed only once. In Iowa’s Senate race Polymarket had Democrat Josh Turek at 51% while Kalshi had Republican Ashley Hinson at 50%. Turek won.
  • Kalshi usually paid first. In the 77 races that had settled on both venues by November 5, Kalshi settled first every time, by a median of 2.6 hours.

Scores

The Brier score is the squared gap between the winner’s price and 1, averaged over races. Zero is perfect, and always guessing 50% scores 0.250. Lower is better.

PolymarketKalshi
Called races scored (listed on that venue)107127
Favourite won91 of 107110 of 127
Brier score (all called races)0.1010.086
Brier score (races both venues listed)0.103 (105)0.104 (105)
Close races (favourite under 65%): favourite won14 of 2611 of 23

The biggest upsets

The called races where the winner was priced lowest at 4 p.m. ET on election day. Prices are scaled so each market’s outcomes add up to 100%, as in our accuracy report.

Race Winner Poly­market Kalshi
Mississippi Senate Scott Colom 14% 14%
TX-09 Leticia Gutierrez 27% 24%
OH-10 Kristina Knickerbocker 28% 31%
South Carolina Senate Annie Andrews 31% 31%
Kansas governor Cindy Holscher 37% 35%
FL-09 Darren Soto 36% 37%
NC-09 Richard Ojeda 36% 36%
Texas governor Gina Hinojosa 38% 38%

Mississippi was the biggest miss of the night: Scott Colom was at about one in seven on both venues and won the Senate seat, a call the AP made eight days after the election. Every close race we tracked is in the accuracy report.

How fast each venue paid

Settlement times for all 129 markets as they stood on November 5, 2026, from each venue’s public data. Polymarket listed 107 of the markets and Kalshi 127.

Settled by (ET) Kalshi (of 127) Polymarket (of 107)
Midnight, election night 51 13
6 a.m., November 4 92 64
Noon, November 4 92 71
Midnight, November 4 to 5 99 77
7:25 a.m., November 5 99 78

The control markets and the late races, in Eastern time:

Market AP call Kalshi paid Poly­market paid
Senate control Nov 3, 11:37 p.m. Nov 4, 12:46 a.m. Nov 4, 5:53 a.m.
House control Nov 4, 1:28 a.m. Nov 4, 1:02 a.m. Nov 4, 8:06 a.m.
Mississippi Senate Nov 11, 5:58 p.m. Nov 11, 6:34 p.m. Nov 11, 9:06 p.m.
Kansas governor Nov 12, 5:43 p.m. Nov 12, 5:49 p.m. Nov 12, 8:54 p.m.
Alaska governor Nov 14, 12:01 a.m. Nov 14, 9:17 a.m. Nov 14, 3:10 a.m.
Alaska Senate Nov 17, 10:19 p.m. Nov 17, 10:59 p.m. Nov 18, 1:36 a.m.

Kalshi settles once a consensus of media organisations projects the winner, which can come before the AP’s call, as it did for House control. Polymarket waits until the AP, Fox News and NBC have all called the race. For the Alaska Senate race, the AP time is that of the AP data update that first showed the call. Polymarket’s times are the close time on its public data, and Kalshi’s its settlement time.

What the numbers don’t show

  • One snapshot. Every price is from 4 p.m. ET on election day, before any votes were counted. Prices later in the evening reflect results, not forecasting.
  • Different race lists. Kalshi listed more races, many of them safe seats, so compare the venues on the 105 races both listed.
  • Small sample of close races. Most races were never in doubt; the 20-odd close races on each venue are what separate a good forecaster from a lucky one.
  • Thin markets. Single House districts trade far less than the control markets and can be moved by one trader.

Related: Accuracy report, race by race · When election markets pay out · 2026 midterms · Election night results · How accurate are prediction markets? · All data