How accurate were prediction markets in the 2026 midterms? On the afternoon of Election Day, before the first polls closed, we recorded the prices of the House-control, Senate-control, Senate and governor markets on Polymarket and Kalshi, plus the House districts both venues listed. This page compares those prices with the results, race by race, and scores each venue.
The headline
Polymarket's 4 p.m. favourite won 91 of the 107 called races it listed, and Kalshi's won 110 of 127. Average Brier scores were 0.101 for Polymarket and 0.086 for Kalshi (lower is better; always guessing 50% scores 0.250). The two venues favoured different winners in 1 race.
Those two averages cover different races. Kalshi listed more safe seats, which lowers its figure, so use the like-for-like row in the scoring table below to compare the venues.
Control of Congress
| Market | Polymarket favourite | Kalshi favourite | Winner | Called by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| House control | Democratic Party 95% | Democratic Party 93% | Democratic Party | AP, 4 Nov |
| Senate control | Democratic Party 75% | Democratic Party 73% | Democratic Party | AP, 3 Nov |
Senate races
| Race | Polymarket favourite | Kalshi favourite | Winner | Called by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | Not listed | Barry Moore 98% | Barry Moore | AP, 3 Nov |
| Alaska | Mary Peltola 70% | Mary Peltola 67% | Mary Peltola | AP, 17 Nov |
| Arkansas | Tom Cotton (R) 96% | Tom Cotton 96% | Tom Cotton | AP, 3 Nov |
| Colorado | Not listed | John Hickenlooper 99% | John Hickenlooper | AP, 3 Nov |
| Delaware | Not listed | Chris Coons 99% | Chris Coons | AP, 3 Nov |
| Florida | Ashley Moody (R) 88% | Ashley Moody 86% | Ashley Moody | AP, 3 Nov |
| Georgia | Jon Ossoff (D) 97% | Jon Ossoff 97% | Jon Ossoff | AP, 3 Nov |
| Idaho | Jim Risch (R) 96% | Jim Risch 96% | Jim Risch | AP, 4 Nov |
| Illinois | Juliana Stratton (D) 99% | Juliana Stratton 98% | Juliana Stratton | AP, 3 Nov |
| Iowa | Josh Turek (D) 51% | Ashley Hinson 50% | Josh Turek | AP, 3 Nov |
| Kansas | Adam Hamilton (D) 64% | Adam Hamilton 64% | Adam Hamilton | AP, 3 Nov |
| Kentucky | Not listed | Andy Barr 96% | Andy Barr | AP, 3 Nov |
| Louisiana | Julia Letlow (R) 84% | Julia Letlow 83% | Julia Letlow | AP, 4 Nov |
| Maine | Troy Jackson (D) 71% | Troy Jackson 69% | Troy Jackson | AP, 4 Nov |
| Massachusetts | Ed Markey (D) >99% | Ed Markey >99% | Ed Markey | AP, 3 Nov |
| Michigan | Abdul El-Sayed (D) 76% | Abdul El-Sayed 75% | Abdul El-Sayed | AP, 4 Nov |
| Minnesota | Peggy Flanagan (D) 92% | Peggy Flanagan 91% | Peggy Flanagan | AP, 4 Nov |
| Mississippi | Cindy Hyde-Smith (R) 87% | Cindy Hyde-Smith 86% | Scott Colom | AP, 11 Nov |
| Montana | Kurt Alme (R) 93% | Kurt Alme 92% | Kurt Alme | AP, 4 Nov |
| Nebraska | Pete Ricketts (R) 71% | Pete Ricketts 72% | Pete Ricketts | AP, 4 Nov |
| New Hampshire | Chris Pappas (D) 96% | Chris Pappas 94% | Chris Pappas | AP, 3 Nov |
| New Jersey | Not listed | Cory Booker 99% | Cory Booker | AP, 3 Nov |
| New Mexico | Not listed | Ben Ray Luján 99% | Ben Ray Luján | AP, 3 Nov |
| North Carolina | Roy Cooper (D) 98% | Roy Cooper 97% | Roy Cooper | AP, 3 Nov |
| Ohio (special) | Sherrod Brown (D) 73% | Sherrod Brown 71% | Sherrod Brown | AP, 3 Nov |
| Oklahoma | Not listed | Kevin Hern 98% | Kevin Hern | AP, 3 Nov |
| Oregon | Not listed | Jeff Merkley >99% | Jeff Merkley | AP, 3 Nov |
| Rhode Island | Not listed | Jack Reed 99% | Jack Reed | AP, 3 Nov |
| South Carolina | Darline Graham Nordone (R) 70% | Darline Graham 69% | Annie Andrews | AP, 3 Nov |
| South Dakota | Not listed | Mike Rounds 94% | Mike Rounds | AP, 4 Nov |
| Tennessee | Not listed | Bill Hagerty 98% | Bill Hagerty | AP, 3 Nov |
| Texas | James Talarico (D) 76% | James Talarico 74% | James Talarico | AP, 3 Nov |
| Virginia | Not listed | Mark Warner 99% | Mark Warner | AP, 3 Nov |
| West Virginia | Not listed | Shelley Moore Capito 98% | Shelley Moore Capito | AP, 3 Nov |
| Wyoming | Not listed | Harriet Hageman 99% | Harriet Hageman | AP, 3 Nov |
Governor races
| Race | Polymarket favourite | Kalshi favourite | Winner | Called by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | Tommy Tuberville (R) 91% | Tommy Tuberville 90% | Tommy Tuberville | AP, 4 Nov |
| Alaska | Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins 87% | Not listed | Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins | AP, 14 Nov |
| Arizona | Katie Hobbs (D) 94% | Katie Hobbs 93% | Katie Hobbs | AP, 4 Nov |
| Arkansas | Not listed | Sarah Huckabee Sanders 97% | Sarah Huckabee Sanders | AP, 3 Nov |
| California | Xavier Becerra 97% | Xavier Becerra 97% | Xavier Becerra | AP, 3 Nov |
| Colorado | Not listed | Phil Weiser 97% | Phil Weiser | AP, 3 Nov |
| Connecticut | Not listed | Ned Lamont 97% | Ned Lamont | AP, 3 Nov |
| Florida | Byron Donalds (R) 63% | Byron Donalds 64% | Byron Donalds | AP, 3 Nov |
| Georgia | Keisha Lance Bottoms (D) 72% | Keisha Lance Bottoms 70% | Keisha Lance Bottoms | AP, 3 Nov |
| Idaho | Not listed | Brad Little 98% | Brad Little | AP, 4 Nov |
| Illinois | JB Pritzker (D) 98% | JB Pritzker 98% | JB Pritzker | AP, 3 Nov |
| Iowa | Rob Sand (D) 88% | Rob Sand 86% | Rob Sand | AP, 3 Nov |
| Kansas | Ty Masterson (R) 64% | Ty Masterson 65% | Cindy Holscher | AP, 12 Nov |
| Maine | Not listed | Hannah Pingree 95% | Hannah Pingree | AP, 3 Nov |
| Maryland | Not listed | Wes Moore 99% | Wes Moore | AP, 3 Nov |
| Massachusetts | Maura Healey (D) 97% | Maura Healey 97% | Maura Healey | AP, 3 Nov |
| Michigan | Jocelyn Benson (D) 95% | Jocelyn Benson 94% | Jocelyn Benson | AP, 4 Nov |
| Minnesota | Amy Klobuchar (D) 98% | Amy Klobuchar 97% | Amy Klobuchar | AP, 4 Nov |
| Nebraska | Jim Pillen (R) 89% | Not listed | Jim Pillen | AP, 4 Nov |
| Nevada | Aaron Ford (D) 83% | Aaron Ford 82% | Aaron Ford | AP, 4 Nov |
| New Hampshire | Kelly Ayotte (R) 85% | Kelly Ayotte 85% | Kelly Ayotte | AP, 4 Nov |
| New Mexico | Deb Haaland (D) 95% | Deb Haaland 95% | Deb Haaland | AP, 3 Nov |
| New York | Kathy Hochul (D) 97% | Kathy Hochul 96% | Kathy Hochul | AP, 3 Nov |
| Ohio | Amy Acton (D) 83% | Amy Acton 81% | Amy Acton | AP, 3 Nov |
| Oklahoma | Mike Mazzei (R) 91% | Mike Mazzei 90% | Mike Mazzei | AP, 3 Nov |
| Oregon | Tina Kotek (D) 85% | Tina Kotek 83% | Tina Kotek | AP, 4 Nov |
| Pennsylvania | Josh Shapiro (D) 98% | Josh Shapiro 98% | Josh Shapiro | AP, 3 Nov |
| Rhode Island | Not listed | Helena Foulkes 97% | Helena Foulkes | AP, 3 Nov |
| South Carolina | Alan Wilson (R) 96% | Alan Wilson 95% | Alan Wilson | AP, 4 Nov |
| South Dakota | Not listed | Larry Rhoden 98% | Larry Rhoden | AP, 3 Nov |
| Tennessee | Marsha Blackburn (R) 93% | Marsha Blackburn 92% | Marsha Blackburn | AP, 4 Nov |
| Texas | Greg Abbott (R) 62% | Greg Abbott 62% | Gina Hinojosa | AP, 3 Nov |
| Vermont | Phil Scott (R) 67% | Phil Scott 67% | Phil Scott | AP, 4 Nov |
| Wisconsin | David Crowley (D) 88% | David Crowley 85% | David Crowley | AP, 3 Nov |
House races traded on both venues
Most single-district House markets are thinly traded, so we score only the districts both Polymarket and Kalshi listed.
| Race | Polymarket favourite | Kalshi favourite | Winner | Called by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AL-02 | Shomari Figures (D) 56% | Shomari Figures 53% | Shomari Figures | AP, 3 Nov |
| AR-02 | French Hill (R) 75% | French Hill 76% | French Hill | AP, 5 Nov |
| AZ-01 | Amish Shah (D) 79% | Amish Shah 80% | Amish Shah | AP, 5 Nov |
| AZ-06 | JoAnna Mendoza (D) 92% | JoAnna Mendoza 92% | JoAnna Mendoza | AP, 5 Nov |
| CA-06 | Democratic Party >99% | Richard Pan 88% | Richard Pan | AP, 4 Nov |
| CA-13 | Adam Gray (D) 94% | Adam Gray 94% | Adam Gray | AP, 4 Nov |
| CA-22 | Randy Villegas (D) 93% | Randy Villegas 93% | Randy Villegas | AP, 4 Nov |
| CO-03 | Jeff Hurd (R) 54% | Jeff Hurd 53% | Jeff Hurd | AP, 6 Nov |
| CO-05 | Jeff Crank (R) 51% | Jeff Crank 51% | Jessica Killin | AP, 5 Nov |
| CO-08 | Manny Rutinel (D) 94% | Manny Rutinel 93% | Manny Rutinel | AP, 3 Nov |
| FL-07 | Ryan Elijah (R) 65% | Ryan Elijah 66% | Ryan Elijah | AP, 10 Nov |
| FL-09 | Dan Green (R) 65% | Dan Green 63% | Darren Soto | AP, 10 Nov |
| FL-11 | Joe Strada (R) 83% | Joe Strada 81% | Joe Strada | AP, 3 Nov |
| FL-12 | Gus Bilirakis (R) 81% | Gus Bilirakis 81% | Gus Bilirakis | AP, 3 Nov |
| FL-13 | Anna Paulina Luna (R) 75% | Anna Paulina Luna 75% | Anna Paulina Luna | AP, 5 Nov |
| FL-14 | Kathy Castor (D) 75% | Kathy Castor 71% | Kathy Castor | AP, 3 Nov |
| FL-22 | Pia Dandiya (D) 63% | Pia Dandiya 62% | Pia Dandiya | AP, 3 Nov |
| FL-25 | Jared Moskowitz (D) 84% | Jared Moskowitz 83% | Jared Moskowitz | AP, 3 Nov |
| FL-26 | Mario Díaz-Balart (R) 86% | Mario Díaz-Balart 85% | Mario Diaz-Balart | AP, 9 Nov |
| FL-27 | María Elvira Salazar (R) 65% | Maria Elvira Salazar 66% | Maria Elvira Salazar | AP, 10 Nov |
| IA-01 | Christina Bohannan (D) 93% | Christina Bohannan 91% | Christina Bohannan | AP, 4 Nov |
| IA-03 | Sarah Trone Garriott (D) 78% | Sarah Trone Garriott 78% | Sarah Trone Garriott | AP, 4 Nov |
| KS-02 | Derek Schmidt (R) 78% | Derek Schmidt 79% | Derek Schmidt | AP, 4 Nov |
| KY-06 | Zach Dembo (D) 61% | Zach Dembo 59% | Zach Dembo | AP, 3 Nov |
| MD-01 | Andy Harris (R) 84% | Andy Harris 83% | Andy Harris | AP, 3 Nov |
| ME-02 | Paul LePage (R) 63% | Paul LePage 59% | Paul LePage | AP, 12 Nov |
| MI-04 | Sean McCann (D) 60% | Sean McCann 59% | Sean McCann | AP, 4 Nov |
| MO-02 | Ann Wagner (R) 60% | Ann Wagner 59% | Fred Wellman | AP, 3 Nov |
| MO-05 | Emanuel Cleaver (D) 98% | Emanuel Cleaver 98% | Emanuel Cleaver | AP, 3 Nov |
| MT-01 | Sam Forstag (D) 60% | Sam Forstag 60% | Sam Forstag | AP, 5 Nov |
| NC-01 | Don Davis (D) 84% | Don Davis 84% | Don Davis | AP, 5 Nov |
| NC-03 | Greg Murphy (R) 58% | Greg Murphy 59% | Raymond Smith Jr. | AP, 17 Nov |
| NC-07 | David Rouzer (R) 76% | David Rouzer 75% | David Rouzer | AP, 16 Nov |
| NC-09 | Richard Hudson (R) 64% | Richard Hudson 64% | Richard Ojeda | AP, 5 Nov |
| NC-11 | Jamie Ager (D) 87% | Jamie Ager 86% | Jamie Ager | AP, 3 Nov |
| NC-13 | Brad Knott (R) 60% | Brad Knott 59% | Paul Barringer | AP, 5 Nov |
| NH-01 | Stefany Shaheen (D) 95% | Stefany Shaheen 95% | Stefany Shaheen | AP, 3 Nov |
| NJ-02 | Jeff Van Drew (R) 55% | Jeff Van Drew 53% | Zack Mullock | AP, 5 Nov |
| NV-02 | David Flippo (R) 51% | David Flippo 51% | Teresa Benitez-Thompson | AP, 4 Nov |
| NY-17 | Cait Conley (D) 53% | Cait Conley 51% | Cait Conley | AP, 5 Nov |
| NY-21 | Anthony Constantino (R) 72% | Anthony Constantino 70% | Anthony Constantino | AP, 6 Nov |
| OH-07 | Brian Poindexter (D) 85% | Brian Poindexter 84% | Brian Poindexter | AP, 4 Nov |
| OH-10 | Mike Turner (R) 73% | Mike Turner 69% | Kristina Knickerbocker | AP, 5 Nov |
| OK-05 | Stephanie Bice (R) 87% | Stephanie Bice 86% | Stephanie Bice | AP, 4 Nov |
| PA-01 | Bob Harvie (D) 69% | Bob Harvie 69% | Bob Harvie | AP, 4 Nov |
| PA-08 | Paige Cognetti (D) 87% | Paige Cognetti 86% | Paige Cognetti | AP, 3 Nov |
| SC-01 | Jenny Costa Honeycutt (R) 53% | Jenny Costa Honeycutt 52% | Nancy Lacore | AP, 6 Nov |
| TN-09 | Brent Taylor (R) 78% | Brent Taylor 78% | Brent Taylor | AP, 5 Nov |
| TX-09 | Alex Mealer (R) 74% | Alex Mealer 76% | Leticia Gutierrez | AP, 4 Nov |
| TX-15 | Bobby Pulido (D) 89% | Bobby Pulido 88% | Bobby Pulido | AP, 4 Nov |
| TX-23 | Brandon Herrera (R) 59% | Brandon Herrera 58% | Katy Padilla Stout | AP, 4 Nov |
| TX-35 | Johnny Garcia (D) 73% | Johnny C. Garcia 74% | Johnny Garcia | AP, 4 Nov |
| VA-01 | Shannon Taylor (D) 75% | Shannon Taylor 75% | Shannon Taylor | AP, 5 Nov |
| VA-02 | Elaine Luria (D) 95% | Elaine Luria 94% | Elaine Luria | AP, 3 Nov |
| VA-05 | John McGuire (R) 58% | John McGuire 60% | John McGuire | AP, 5 Nov |
| VA-06 | Ben Cline (R) 94% | Ben Cline 94% | Ben Cline | AP, 3 Nov |
| WA-03 | Marie Gluesenkamp Perez (D) 90% | Marie Gluesenkamp Perez 89% | Marie Gluesenkamp Perez | AP, 4 Nov |
| WI-03 | Rebecca Cooke (D) 88% | Rebecca Cooke 87% | Rebecca Cooke | AP, 4 Nov |
Scoring the venues
We use the Brier score, the standard measure for probability forecasts: for each race, the squared difference between the eventual winner’s price and 1. Zero is perfect; always guessing 50% scores 0.250. Lower is better. Because the two venues didn’t list the same races, the fairest comparison is the row that only counts races both listed.
| Polymarket | Kalshi | |
|---|---|---|
| Called races scored (listed on that venue) | 107 | 127 |
| Favourite won | 91 of 107 | 110 of 127 |
| Brier score (all called races) | 0.101 | 0.086 |
| Brier score (races both venues listed) | 0.103 (105) | 0.104 (105) |
| Close races (favourite under 65%): favourite won | 14 of 26 | 11 of 23 |
Upsets and close calls
Every called race where the winner was priced under 65% on at least one venue at 4 p.m. ET:
- Iowa Senate: Polymarket had Josh Turek at 51%; Kalshi had Josh Turek at 50%.
- Kansas Senate: Polymarket had Adam Hamilton at 64%; Kalshi had Adam Hamilton at 64%.
- Mississippi Senate: Polymarket had Scott Colom at 14%; Kalshi had Scott Colom at 14%.
- South Carolina Senate: Polymarket had Annie Andrews at 31%; Kalshi had Annie Andrews at 31%.
- Florida governor: Polymarket had Byron Donalds at 63%; Kalshi had Byron Donalds at 64%.
- Kansas governor: Polymarket had Cindy Holscher at 37%; Kalshi had Cindy Holscher at 35%.
- Texas governor: Polymarket had Gina Hinojosa at 38%; Kalshi had Gina Hinojosa at 38%.
- AL-02: Polymarket had Shomari Figures at 56%; Kalshi had Shomari Figures at 53%.
- CO-03: Polymarket had Jeff Hurd at 54%; Kalshi had Jeff Hurd at 53%.
- CO-05: Polymarket had Jessica Killin at 49%; Kalshi had Jessica Killin at 49%.
- FL-07: Polymarket had Ryan Elijah at 65%; Kalshi had Ryan Elijah at 66%.
- FL-09: Polymarket had Darren Soto at 36%; Kalshi had Darren Soto at 37%.
- FL-22: Polymarket had Pia Dandiya at 63%; Kalshi had Pia Dandiya at 62%.
- FL-27: Polymarket had Maria Elvira Salazar at 65%; Kalshi had Maria Elvira Salazar at 66%.
- KY-06: Polymarket had Zach Dembo at 61%; Kalshi had Zach Dembo at 59%.
- ME-02: Polymarket had Paul LePage at 63%; Kalshi had Paul LePage at 59%.
- MI-04: Polymarket had Sean McCann at 60%; Kalshi had Sean McCann at 59%.
- MO-02: Polymarket had Fred Wellman at 40%; Kalshi had Fred Wellman at 41%.
- MT-01: Polymarket had Sam Forstag at 60%; Kalshi had Sam Forstag at 60%.
- NC-03: Polymarket had Raymond Smith Jr. at 42%; Kalshi had Raymond Smith Jr. at 41%.
- NC-09: Polymarket had Richard Ojeda at 36%; Kalshi had Richard Ojeda at 36%.
- NC-13: Polymarket had Paul Barringer at 41%; Kalshi had Paul Barringer at 41%.
- NJ-02: Polymarket had Zack Mullock at 45%; Kalshi had Zack Mullock at 47%.
- NV-02: Polymarket had Teresa Benitez-Thompson at 49%; Kalshi had Teresa Benitez-Thompson at 49%.
- NY-17: Polymarket had Cait Conley at 53%; Kalshi had Cait Conley at 51%.
- OH-10: Polymarket had Kristina Knickerbocker at 28%; Kalshi had Kristina Knickerbocker at 31%.
- SC-01: Polymarket had Nancy Lacore at 47%; Kalshi had Nancy Lacore at 48%.
- TX-09: Polymarket had Leticia Gutierrez at 27%; Kalshi had Leticia Gutierrez at 24%.
- TX-23: Polymarket had Katy Padilla Stout at 41%; Kalshi had Katy Padilla Stout at 42%.
- VA-05: Polymarket had John McGuire at 58%; Kalshi had John McGuire at 60%.
Every race on our list has been called.
Methodology
- Prices. The latest price of each outcome on Polymarket and Kalshi (for Kalshi the last trade, for Polymarket the outcome price its market API reports; see our methodology) at 21:00 UTC (4 p.m. ET) on November 3, 2026, from their public APIs, recorded automatically by Prediction Tape. Prices within each market are scaled to add up to 100% before scoring, because the latest prices rarely sum exactly to 100%.
- Races. Control of the House and Senate, every Senate and governor race our snapshot recorded on either venue, and the House districts it recorded on both. The snapshot took each venue’s open events at that time, so a very thin market can be missing. Where a venue lists both a party market and a candidate market for the same race, we use one of them.
- Results. The calling organisation and date are shown for each race. Every race on our list has now been called. NC-03 and NC-07 were called between two of our checks, so the date shown is that of the latest AP results update, which already had each race called.
- Scoring. Brier score on the eventual winner’s scaled price: (1 − price)². The “favourite” is the outcome with the highest price.
- Limits. One snapshot, taken before any votes were counted. Prices later in the evening reflect results, not forecasting. Thin markets can be moved by single traders. Most races were never in doubt, so the close races that separate the venues are a small sample. The last races to be called were close ones.
Download the data (CSV): every outcome's 4 p.m. price on each venue, normalised probability and whether it won.
Related: Midterms 2026: how the markets did · Election night hub · 2026 midterms · Weekly price gaps · November 2026 recap · All data