Who will win NFL Rookie of the Year? The current favourites are at the top of the tables below. Kalshi and Polymarket both list the two AP awards for the 2026 season, Offensive and Defensive Rookie of the Year, and these are the live odds side by side. Last season’s winners were Tetairoa McMillan of the Panthers on offence and Carson Schwesinger of the Browns on defence.
Offensive Rookie of the Year odds
Live odds · both venues
AP Offensive Rookie of the Year
Latest price of each outcome, read as a chance. Names are matched across venues automatically; check each venue's rules before comparing, as resolution wording can differ. Updated every few minutes.
Defensive Rookie of the Year odds
Live odds · both venues
AP Defensive Rookie of the Year
Latest price of each outcome, read as a chance. Names are matched across venues automatically; check each venue's rules before comparing, as resolution wording can differ. Updated every few minutes.
Each price is the cost of a contract that pays $1 if that player wins, so 25¢ means about a 25% chance. Only one player wins each award, so each column should add up to roughly 100% once you count the players not shown. Polymarket’s two markets have traded a few tens of thousands of dollars each, so a single order can move a price there.
How these markets settle
On Kalshi, each contract resolves Yes if that player wins the AP award named in the market for the 2026-27 season. Polymarket resolves to the AP winner too; if several winners are announced, it goes to the listed last name that comes first alphabetically, and if no winner is declared by February 28, 2027 it resolves to “Other”. These are the Associated Press awards, so another rookie honour doesn’t count: last season Tyler Shough won the separate Pepsi Zero Sugar Rookie of the Year honour, while McMillan took the AP award. Rules as published on each market, checked November 20, 2026. Kalshi states that it isn’t affiliated with the league.
What moves these prices
- Quarterbacks on offence. A rookie starter touches the ball on every snap, so a strong run can move the market quickly.
- Sacks on defence. Pass rushers post the numbers voters see first, while linebackers and defensive backs need tackles, takeaways or team success.
- Injuries and benchings. One absence can reset both tables in a week.
- The second half of the season. A late surge counts, since voting comes after the regular season.
Worked example
Say a rookie trades at 30¢ and you buy 100 contracts for $30. If that player wins, they pay $100, a $70 profit before fees. If not, you lose the $30. You don’t have to hold until the award: you can sell at the market price at any time.
FAQ
Who is favoured for Offensive Rookie of the Year?
Who won NFL Rookie of the Year last season?
When are the awards announced?
Is there a Polymarket market?
Sources, checked November 4, 2026, with market rules rechecked November 20, 2026:
- Pro Football Hall of Fame: AP award finalists for the 2025 season
- Wikipedia: AP NFL Rookie of the Year
- Sports Illustrated: Giants rookies passed over
- Kalshi and Polymarket market rules for the 2026-27 awards
Related: NFL Coach of the Year odds · NFL MVP odds · Super Bowl odds · NFL playoff odds · NBA Rookie of the Year odds